Wooden Shutters vs. Composite Shutters: Which Is Right for You?

Choosing new shutters for your home? You’re not alone. For many homeowners, the big question comes down to which shutter manufacturer is the best choice for your home and budget. Whether you’re interested in premium wood shutters or hybrid poly shutters—choose ShutterSMART with options for any space.

At ShutterSMART, we build our shutters right here in North America, so no matter which material you choose, you’re getting custom-made quality, built faster, and built to last than import shutters with overseas timelines.

Here’s how to decide which style fits your home (and your lifestyle) best.

The Classic: Wooden Interior Shutters

There’s a reason real wood never goes out of style. Our Miramonte Painted Wood Shutters and Miramonte Premier Stained Shutters are crafted from premium hardwood trusted for its durability, and beautiful finishes.

Whether you choose a 100% American basswood shutter that we hand-sand and finish, or a painted shutter with our exclusive 4 Coat Baked-In Finish™ for color that stays brilliant year after year, ShutterSMART Miramonte wood shutters bring warmth and timeless character to every room.

Why homeowners love our wood shutters:

• Natural texture and rich character that never fades from fashion.
• Custom paint and stain options for a tailored look.
• Perfect for living rooms, dining spaces, or any place you want to impress.

The Durable: Poly Composite Shutters

If you’re after simplicity, strength, and easy upkeep, our AllView Poly Shutters are made for you.

Built from ultra-durable Polyresin, these shutters won’t chip, crack, or warp—no matter how humid your kitchen or bathroom gets. They’re reinforced with solid corner blocks for strength and insulation, and finished with our signature WoodTex™ surface, giving you the soft look of painted wood without the maintenance.

Plus, every AllView shutter comes standard with our hidden tilt rod system for a clean, modern aesthetic.

Why homeowners love poly:

• Easy to clean and built to handle everyday life.
• Moisture-resistant—perfect for kitchens, baths, basements, and laundry rooms.
• A sleek, seamless look that fits modern spaces.

The Best of Both Worlds: Hybrid Woodcore Shutters

Not ready to pick a side? Our ShutterSMART PolyClad Woodcore Shutters give you the beauty of wood with the durability of poly hybrid material. Inside, a solid wood core adds strength and stability. Outside, a polyresin sleeve protects against moisture and wear. Together, they create one of the most advanced shutter systems on the market—complete with our TwistLock™ Tilt Rod and authentic WoodTex™ finish.

Why homeowners love hybrids:

• Real wood strength with a low-maintenance finish.
• Won’t warp, peel, or fade over time.
• Designed to fit virtually any window or door in any room.

So, Which One Is Right for You?

• Choose Wood if you want timeless warmth and artisan craftsmanship.
• Choose Poly if you want a clean, durable, easy-care shutter that still looks high-end.
• Choose Hybrid if you want both—the beauty and thermal insultation of wood with the resilience of poly.

Whichever you choose, every ShutterSMART shutter is Made in North America, backed by a Limited Lifetime Warranty, and installed by trusted local pros who make it look effortless.

Experience the ShutterSMART Difference for Yourself

Skip the guessing!

Book your design consultation, and our experienced team will answer your questions and help you choose the shutter that’s right for your style and your home.